GUEST EDITOR'S INTRODUCTION—THE MANY FACES OF TRUST


by Sotirios Terzis

April 2009—TRUST MANAGEMENT

In recent years, trust in computing has been receiving increased attention. With the emphasis on loosely coupled and decentralized systems and the advent of service orientation, trust management has moved beyond the domains of security, multiagent systems, and e-commerce to become a key concern across all aspects of computing. However, there's currently little agreement on what trust really means and what the best way of managing it is. In fact, as Steffen Staab pointed out in his aptly named editorial "The Pudding of Trust," we have ended up with a pudding of things rather than a solid definition. As time passes, this pudding has become richer in taste and ingredients.

Work on trust management is often divided into security-oriented and non-security-oriented. The former tends to adopt a more restricted view of trust where trustworthiness is equated to the degree to which an entity or object is considered secure. The latter adopts a wider view of trust more akin to the multifaceted view of trust explored in social sciences. In the context of service orientation, this socially oriented concept of trust is extended to include a view of trust as a mechanism for achieving, maintaining, and reasoning about the quality of service and interactions.

However, a closer examination of the concept of trust as used within these different areas reveals that the fundamental difference is in the form that trustworthiness as a property takes. The traditional view is that trustworthiness is an absolute property that an entity either has or doesn't have. This view of trust was articulated in the context of computing systems in general by the US Department of Defense in the early '80s and in the context of software by David Parnas and his colleagues in the early '90s. It has been the basis of much security-oriented work on trust management and is exemplified by the work on credential-based trust management by Matt Blaze and his colleagues.

In credential-based trust, principals' trustworthiness is determined on the basis of the credentials they possess, and trust management is about specifying and interpreting security policies, credentials, and relationships. In the same area is trust negotiation where, motivated by privacy concerns, principals iteratively disclose certified digital credentials that verify their properties to establish mutual trust. Beyond credential-based trust, security-oriented trust management also includes distributed trust, where replication and threshold cryptography are used to reduce the vulnerability of an ensemble of a service's replicas, making it more trustworthy. This view of trust has also been the basis of trusted computing, a collection of technologies that, when combined, help establish a more secure operating environment on various hardware platforms. In the context of software engineering, this view of trust has been extended beyond security to include other software qualities, and has been the basis of the work on trusted components and services. In this context, component and service trustworthiness is determined on the basis of provided qualities guaranteed through formal verification (Bertrand Meyer's "high road" towards trusted components).

In contrast, the modern view of trust is that trustworthiness is a measureable property that different entities have in various degrees. Trust management is about managing the risks of interactions between entities. Trust is determined on the basis of evidence (personal experiences, observations, recommendations, and overall reputation) and is situationall—that is, an entity's trustworthiness differs depending on the context of the interaction.

This view of trust has been the basis of most work in trust management in multiagent systems. In these systems, trust is used as a measure of agents' competence and benevolence, often abstracting away from the complex factors that can drive agent behavior. The notion of agent benevolence includes both concerns about malicious behavior, typical in security-oriented work, and about selfish behavior that can be counterproductive for the system. Selfish behavior is also a concern in the context of peer-to-peer systems, where free riding can be a serious problem and trust and reputation schemes have been used to alleviate it.

This view of trust is also similar to the human notion of trust. As a result, it has been the basis of work on computer-mediated trust between users and work on building human trust in computer systems. Both of these aspects are essential in the context of e-commerce systems. When the focus is on human-human interaction, simple models of trust that abstract away from the complex factors that determine human trustworthiness are usually preferable. On the other hand, in the case of human-computer interaction, sophisticated models of trust that try to capture all aspects that affect human trust are often preferable. In the context of service orientation, as services become more sophisticated with autonomic capabilities, sophisticated models of trust and reputation have become the focus of research.

This month on Computing Now, a collection of articles aims to provide a taste of the current pudding of trust. "Dynamic Trust Management" by Matt Blaze and his colleagues extends previous work on credential-based trust in the context of service-oriented architectures by introducing dynamism with respect to service availability and situation awareness. "Reputation Bootstrapping for Trust Establishment among Web Services" by Zaki Malik and Athman Bouguettaya focuses on evidence-based trust in the context of service-oriented architectures. It contrasts a number of techniques for bootstrapping the reputation of newcomer services. "How Do We Build Trust into E-Commerce Web Sites?" by Ejike Ofuonye and his colleagues identifies the principal factors affecting user trust in e-commerce Web sites with the aim of providing developers with some guidance on the issues they should focus on. "A Multiagent System for Coordination Ambulances for Emergency Medical Services" by Beatriz Lopez, Bianca Innocenti, and Didac Busquets describes a system that uses evidence-based trust as a measure of the competence of emergency transportation agents to accurately estimate the time needed to reach an emergency. Finally, Keith W. Miller and Jeffrey Voas's article "The Metaphysics of Software Trust" advocates for a more transparent approach in software licensing to encourage software trust motivated by an analysis of the implications of the nonphysical nature of software and the trust relationships between the stakeholders of software artifacts.

Related links 

Sotirios Terzis is a lecturer at the Department of Computer and Information Sciences, University of Strathclyde. You can contact him at Sotirios dot Terzis at cis dot strath dot ac dot uk.

Theme — TRUST MANAGMENT

Dynamic Trust Management
Trust management forms the basis for communicating policy among system elements and demands credential checking for access to all virtual private service resources—along with careful evaluation of credentials against specified policies—before a party can be trusted.

Reputation Bootstrapping for Trust Establishment among Web Services
Reputation systems rely on past information to establish trust among unknown participants. The authors examine different techniques for fairly and accurately bootstrapping newcomers' reputations in a service-oriented environment.

How Do We Build Trust into E-commerce Web Sites?
Trust is a subjective, user-centric, context-dependent concept, and is thus difficult to define universally. To address this issue, the authors reviewed the available literature on the topic, examining 28 relevant publications in depth to identify relationships among factors that impact trust.

A Multiagent System for Coordinating Ambulances for Emergency Medical Services
This system uses an auction mechanism based on trust to select an ambulance for emergency patient transportation.

The Metaphysics of Software Trust
This article focuses on the "trust" portion of the trust and dependability duet. Both concepts are important and delicately intertwined, but in this short discussion, the authors say they can only hope to explore one.

What's New

Communication Smart
In an attempt to help IT professionals advance their careers, the former EIC of IT Professional magazine describes the first of six
“soft skills” everyone should master to move ahead.

You Are What You Read
Given that useful knowledge in software engineering has a half-life of about five years, reading remains an excellent way to replenish this vanishing resource for the diligent software engineer.

The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Data
Problems that involve human interaction aren’t neatly solvable. Instead, embrace the domain’s complexity by harnessing the power of data.

Parallel Programming with Skeletons
Various software models aim to make parallel programming possible, trading efficiency for abstraction or vice versa, but how about getting both?

Serious Games for Immersive Cultural Training: Creating a Living World
The 3D Asymmetric Domain Analysis and Training model uses visual, auditory, behavioral, and cultural models for immersive cultural training using the living-world construct.

Digital Television for Mobile Devices
A survey of mobile television technologies anayzes technical characteristics for each mobile TV solution, discusses specifications and standards, and rpesents possible future developments.

Voice Processors Based on the Human Hearing System
This article describes an emerging signal-processing chip for use in mobile phones and PCs. The system uses a custom set of algorithms based on the human hearing system to provide noise reduction and acoustic echo cancellation in noisy environments.

A New Era of Presidential Security: The President and His BlackBerry
Although Obama persuaded his security staff to let him keep using his BlackBerry (or a BlackBerry-like handheld device), it is not clear how, exactly, the device was modified to ensure extra security.

Information-Seeking Support Systems
Seeking information for learning, decision making, and other complex mental activities requires tools and support services that aid people in managing, analyzing, and sharing retrieved information.

Ten Ideas for Policymakers to Drive Digital Progress
Policymakers must create the right environment for technological progress. This article offers 10 guiding principles for creating technology policy that spurs and sustains digital progress.

What Wearable Augmented Reality Can Do for You
This article takes a look at augmented reality—what it is and what it can do for you.

Hybrid BIST Scheme for Multiple Heterogenous Embedded Memories
This novel hybrid BIST architecture reduces this routing penalty, while allowing at-speed test and diagnosis of memory cores.

Voice Processors Based on the Human Hearing System
This article describes an emerging signal-processing chip for use in mobile phones and PCs.