Issue No. 02 - Feb. (2013 vol. 39)
DOI Bookmark: http://doi.ieeecomputersociety.org/10.1109/TSE.2010.111
Joseph Lawrance , Wentworth Institute of Technology, Boston
Christopher Bogart , Oregon State University, Corvallis
Margaret Burnett , Oregon State University, Corvallis
Rachel Bellamy , IBM TJ Watson Research Center, Hawthorne
Kyle Rector , Oregon State University, Corvallis
Scott D. Fleming , Oregon State University, Corvallis
Many theories of human debugging rely on complex mental constructs that offer little practical advice to builders of software engineering tools. Although hypotheses are important in debugging, a theory of navigation adds more practical value to our understanding of how programmers debug. Therefore, in this paper, we reconsider how people go about debugging in large collections of source code using a modern programming environment. We present an information foraging theory of debugging that treats programmer navigation during debugging as being analogous to a predator following scent to find prey in the wild. The theory proposes that constructs of scent and topology provide enough information to describe and predict programmer navigation during debugging, without reference to mental states such as hypotheses. We investigate the scope of our theory through an empirical study of 10 professional programmers debugging a real-world open source program. We found that the programmers' verbalizations far more often concerned scent-following than hypotheses. To evaluate the predictiveness of our theory, we created an executable model that predicted programmer navigation behavior more accurately than comparable models that did not consider information scent. Finally, we discuss the implications of our results for enhancing software engineering tools.
Debugging, Navigation, Topology, Programming environments, Predictive models, Approximation methods, empirical software engineering, Information foraging theory, debugging, software maintenance, programmer navigation, information scent
R. Bellamy, M. Burnett, C. Bogart, J. Lawrance, K. Rector and S. D. Fleming, "How Programmers Debug, Revisited: An Information Foraging Theory Perspective," in IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering, vol. 39, no. , pp. 197-215, 2013.