The Community for Technology Leaders

A Distance Measurement Platform Dedicated to Electrical Engineering

Noëlle Lewis
Michel Billaud
Didier Geoffroy
Philippe Cazenave
Thomas Zimmer, IEEE

Pages: pp. 312-319

Abstract—This paper presents the remote laboratory eLab, dedicated to electrical engineering education. eLab is a flexible measurement platform that permits to run more than 130 experiments in the fields of electronics and microelectronics. The instructor can choose or create different types of pedagogical scenarios, covering teaching requirements from undergraduate to graduate levels. Furthermore, eLab implementation and use do not require any commercial software. Its reliability has been proven during many practical classes in France and other countries. eLab is now a key component of the Bordeaux University e-Learning material in electrical engineering. In the field of analog integrated circuits design, eLab offers a unique measurement solution, which can be combined to traditional circuit simulation sessions.

Index Terms—e-Learning tools, remote laboratories, electrical engineering, integrated circuits, analog design and test.


Net-based techniques begin to be widely used in education. In sciences education, the experimental method is an essential point of the pedagogy and students must face it during practical sessions. Moreover, it is an opportunity to develop the students understanding, autonomy, and finally, increase their interest in the topic. In the electrical engineering (EE) curriculum, an important part is devoted to the implementation of electrical functions involved in signal processing. The physical realization of the function leads to nonidealities that must be quantified by electrical measurements. A net-based laboratory for characterizing electronic circuits has many advantages: It allows sharing high-quality instruments and full-custom circuits, which could not be duplicated in several stations, for cost reasons; the net-based access allows the users to launch experiments and analyze the results anywhere, as often as they want.

The eLab platform is dedicated to the characterization of electrical components and circuits of analog signal processing. In that domain, there is an important evolution between the undergraduate level and the graduate level, which finally follows the thematic progression from electronics to microelectronics. First, the student must face with measurement techniques and deduce some basic parameters or properties; low-cost equipment can be sufficient for that preliminary teaching. In graduate-level curriculum, the context becomes microelectronics and the future Electrical Engineer must get knowledge and practice on Integrated Circuit (IC) design and test. In digital design, programmable devices like FPGA offer many possibilities to develop consistent and reusable practical experiments. In analog design, the practical experiments are often reduced in software simulation sessions.

eLab is a flexible measurement platform which gives access to a huge number of electronics and microelectronics devices or building blocks, with different types of pedagogical scenarios, covering teaching requirements from undergraduate to graduate levels. eLab implementation and use do not require any commercial software. Its reliability has been proven during many practical classes, and eLab is now a key component of Bordeaux University pedagogical material in EE. It offers especially a unique alternative to software simulations in analog IC design and test, due to the so-called Cyberchips.

The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 summarizes the requirements of a remote lab, taking examples in a review of existing solutions; Section 3 gives a brief history of the previous projects that made the eLab concept emerge. The rest of the paper shows how eLab implementation choices fill the previously listed requirements: Section 4 describes the eLab hardware/software architecture; Section 5 develops eLab pedagogical organization and pertinence; and Section 6 proposes three examples of eLab practical use, at different levels of the curriculum. Finally, a conclusion is proposed in Section 7.

State of the Art and Remote Lab Requirements

A literature review of remote laboratories is provided in [ 1]. All platforms implement the same software/hardware architecture paradigm: a device under test is connected to a local computer which communicates with a remote computer (the user) through a certain middleware. The different solutions may be classified per scientific domain and per software implementation choices.

In electronics domain, several platforms exist for the characterization of components or functional blocks [ 2], [ 3], [ 4], [ 5], [ 6], [ 7], [ 8], [ 9], [ 10], [ 11], [ 12], [ 13]. Generally, a set of typical components is connected to instruments through a specific test fixture and the user is invited to make some measurement choices (input waveform, amplitude, frequency range, power supply, etc.), then he launches the experiment and can display or record the results. Each remote lab is often focused on one main topic which can be: circuit theory and Kirchhoff laws [ 2], [ 4], [ 8], design and test of oscillators or filtering functions [ 2], [ 6], [ 8], [ 9], [ 11], [ 12], characterization of microelectronics components [ 3] (diodes), [ 5], [ 6] (transistors), [ 7] (CMOS operational amplifiers), or characterization of HF devices [ 10], [ 13].

In remote labs, software applications are needed: 1) for the link between the device and local computer (instruments drivers), 2) for the link between the local and remote computers (middleware), and 3) for the link between the remote computer and its user (human computer interface). Two strategies mainly arise: the use of proprietary languages like Labview and Matlab-Simulink [ 3], [ 4], [ 6], [ 9], [ 12] and the use of standard programming languages (Java, PHP, etc.) [ 2], [ 5], [ 8], [ 10], [ 13].

The important features of a remote lab are: availability, security, flexibility, portability, and implementation cost.

Availability is related to free user access and management of multiuser requests. When many users want to access the same instrument, the first in first out (FIFO) sequencing method seems to be the most efficient, because it avoids booking procedures [ 2], [ 5], [ 11], [ 12]. However, for [ 10], this simple sharing access does not permit to implement a collaborative learning strategy. Availability is also enhanced when the user's computer interface does not need any commercial software.

Security is related to both remote hardware and data transfer on the middleware. The first point can be solved by implementing a software validation of the user's inputs, in order to protect the instruments and devices, and the second point requires at least a user authentication protocol.

Flexibility is related to the number of available experimental units and the possibility to use them in different pedagogical scenarios, at different levels in the curriculum. It is also related to the facility to add or change an experiment in the platform. Among the reviewed remote labs, many offer only one or a few number of specific devices under test. The use of a programmable device [ 12] or a switching matrix between instruments and test boards [ 5], [ 6], [ 7], [ 13] can improve the platform flexibility. Another important point is software solutions reusability [ 10], [ 13].

Portability is an important feature for the future system development and possible migrations. In that respect, the platform-independent languages and open-source components should be used as much as possible; furthermore, that choice limits the implementation cost.

eLab Brief History

eLab was developed in the framework of several European initiatives.

Remote on-distance measurements have been performed for more than 10 years at Bordeaux 1 University, France. During this period, different approaches have been developed. The first approach has been carried out via the European project called "RETWINE," which stands for Remote Worldwide Instrumentation Network. The basic idea was to share powerful lab instruments via the WWW [ 14]. Starting from this experience, we wanted to address others remote lab issues: how to design an adequate experiment and how to introduce it in course packages. This approach has been developed in the framework of European Community SOCRATES-MINERVA project called "eMerge" [ 15]. This project was dedicated to the development of an innovative and advanced educational network structure to disseminate online laboratory experiments to support engineering and sciences education. We have examined acceptance, usability, learning effect, and usefulness. The learning effect was also measured by knowledge tests [ 16]. The next step was to address pedagogical aspects in the microelectronics engineering domain. Practical learning of analog integrated circuit design is often based on circuit simulations and not on real testing. We decided to overcome this weakness by including a complete set of analog building blocks in our remote platform. The basic building blocks have been implemented on two chips, the Cyberchips, which were manufactured within a Multiwafer Project [ 17], [ 18]. Thus, a variety of typical building blocks for analog IC design have been made available for measurement and characterization via the eLab platform [ 18]. This work has been carried out in the context of the UNIT project and is part of its platform [ 19].

Today, eLab is used in the curriculum of EE, in high schools or universities, for undergraduate and graduate students, in an open international network. Our current main partners are: Sfax Superior Institute of Electronics and Communications (Tunisia), Dublin Institute of Technology (Ireland), Tampere Polytechnical University of Applied Sciences (Finland), and Catholic Polytechnical University of Bruges-Ostend (Belgium).

eLab Architecture

eLab is a Web-based platform which allows users to perform real electronic measurements on a wide variety of experiments in EE.

Availability was the main objective during the design phase: it is possible to run many sessions simultaneously, on the same topic, without any booking, as the system manages concurrent access to the hardware (instruments and circuits) transparently. Moreover, only standard open Web technologies (HTML, Java, and Javascript) are involved and no specific software has to be installed on the user side. So, eLab is available for students to work anytime from everywhere.

Users of eLab are given access to so-called textbooks. A textbook is a group of PDF, HTML, etc., documents containing course material, documentation, and a set of proposed measurements about one topic. The experimental data they collect are stored in a personal notebook.

A local database of accounts was first used for the authentication of a small number of local users. Over the time, several Single sign-on (SSO) plugins have been added when it became necessary to integrate eLab to the Ulysse [ 20] pedagogical platform of Bordeaux 1 University, then to the eMerge portal [ 21], and finally, to the University top-level portal [ 22].

Measurements are performed through a simple form-based interface; according to the textbook, users have to answer questions about the experimental results, which are stored in a notebook to be reviewed later by the teachers.

Experimental results can be seen as arrays of numbers, curves (generated by GNUplot), and also through an interactive Java applet which provides easy calculation of slopes near interesting points.

The measurement time is relatively short (typically, 20 to 40 s). Besides, students don't start measurements too frequently because they also have to understand the course material and the experimental data they collected. Consequently, the system load is rather low. Practically, we seldom observe more than two or three measurements in the queue, even with 20 users working simultaneously on eLab. Most of the time, users don't have to wait at all.

However, in order to attenuate the likely unpleasant experience of waiting, a feedback is provided to the user through a real-time view of the on-going measurements (a motorized camera automatically zooms on the different active instruments), together with the list of the pending jobs.

The user interface follows an object-oriented design: each type of experiment is managed by a separate object created from a dynamically loaded class. This object is responsible for

  • HTML presentation, code generation for forms, and results displaying,
  • user's input data validation (including checking hardware limitations),
  • requesting the instrument server to start a measurement through an SOAP call,
  • storing/retrieving the results in the user's notebook.

Since June 2009, there are approximately 150 experiments managed by three main classes Freqdomain, Timedomain, and DC. The latter is by and large the most complex with 29 subclasses to manage all the hardware configurations of 80 separate types of experiments.

Fig. 1 gives an overview of eLab architecture.


Figure    Fig. 1. Architecture of eLab platform.

The instrument server has three layers: at the bottom level, each type of instrument is driven by a specific class: for example, a PowerSupply has methods to set its output voltage and get the current level. At the middle level, a PHP script coordinates the work of instruments, power supplies, and switching matrix, in order to perform a type of measurement. The top level presents these measurements as SOAP Web Services.

The current implementation of eLab runs on two low-end computers, with the classical Linux Apache MySQL PHP (LAMP) setup.

The front-end computer runs the Web server with the eLab application; it also hosts the database with accounts, notebooks, and results.

The instrument server is hosted on a local network; it drives the instruments and the two switching matrices (through parallel and serial ports) that can operate simultaneously, with separate queues. A specific extension of PHP has been written in order to drive the GPIB-IEEE-488 interface card directly from PHP scripts; it is now available as part of the open-source PHP5-GPIB package of Linux/Debian [ 23].

The switching matrix for time- and frequency-domain measurements connects one device/circuit under test (75 among a maximum of 128) to an AC Gain-Phase Analyzer (HP 4194) for frequency-domain measurements, or a function generator (Agilent 33220A) coupled to a digital oscilloscope (Agilent 54621A) for time-domain measurements. The device under test is also connected to power supply (Agilent 3649A).

The switching matrix for DC measurements connects 25 building blocks from the so-called Cyberchips to three DC source meters (Keithley 2400) and a power supply (Agilent 3649A).

eLab Pedagogical Organization and Pertinence

In this section, we will see how the previously described material can be organized in e-Learning pedagogical resources.

The current version of eLab results from a 10-year-old history, and we now clearly see the interest of this tool for EE education.

A set of pedagogical resources is available on eLab site, which can be used at different levels of the Bachelor or Master curricula. They are listed in Table 1.

Table 1. Elab Available Resources

Each pedagogical resource is associated to a textbook, which contains a summary of the objectives, a short description of the circuits under test, and several preformatted measurement sessions. One specific experiment can be run by the teacher, as an illustration of a theoretical course, in a multimedia equipped amphitheatre. More frequently, a subset of these pedagogical resources is used during practical courses by a class of students. Students are expected to study the characteristics of circuits, make calculations and practical measurements, and answer questions. Results and answers are stored in the student's notebooks, so they can be retrieved, analyzed, and printed later.

For resources 1-7, the circuits are implemented with discrete components on Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs); for resource 8, Specific Integrated Circuits ( Cyberschips) are connected to DC instruments. These Cyberchips [ 17] have been designed in 2003, with a $0.8\mu{\rm m}$ BiCMOS technology; they integrate all typical building blocks used in analog IC [ 24].

5.1 The Instructor Point of View

The resources that are listed in Table 1 have been designed by teachers of Bordeaux 1 University, in order to be included in specific teaching modules. The task of designing a new resource is quite easy. The final document must be in HTML format, but instructors often use their usual text editor with an automatic format translator. The textbook document contains links to the specific measurements. Teachers have access to a list of available measurements (individual test units, formatted for DC, AC, or time-domain measurement), stored in the database, with information and description data for all test units (site identifier, schematic, photography of the PCB, components values, power supply, circuit function, and key words). Fig. 2 shows a partial view of this list.

Graphic: Fig. 2. Part of the 
eLab test units' database.

Figure    Fig. 2. Part of the eLab test units' database.

From our experience, we know that during the first semester, students must be closely guided in their experimental approach, while it is important to stimulate autonomy and evaluate the experimental approach of graduate-level students. Consequently, the textbooks of resources 1-7 are step-by-step descriptions of the practical course. Resource 8 has been implemented differently: it is composed of many independent textbooks, one textbook for each test configuration and each component. The way to combine these test units is up to the user and gives the opportunity to emphasize the experimental approach and the meaning of the measured results (Which measurement? Why? How to exploit it?).

At the end of a practical session, the instructors can get the notebooks which result from the answers of the students with related curves. These e-reports are automatically edited (for example, in PDF format) and can be used by the instructors for the students' evaluation.

5.2 The Student Point of View

Students are quickly comfortable with the process of launching and retrieving measurements. The distant access to eLab allows them to finish a part of the work at home or to efficiently prepare one practical session.

Questionnaires were used to obtain the students' views as to acceptance, usability, learning effect, and usefulness in studying and vocational terms [ 16].

The students' answers are summarized in Table 2.

Table 2. Parameters of the Questionnaire Scales

The acceptance scale scores an average result ( ${\rm M} = 3.62$ ), as does the usefulness scale ( ${\rm M} = 3.36$ ). However, the usability of the Internet experiments does much better ( ${\rm M} = 4.14$ ).

Looking at the acceptance scale, it is interesting to note that students enjoyed working with the experiments ( ${\rm M} = 3.97$ ). The fact that the experiments were not carried out in a physical lab did not disturb them ( ${\rm M} = 4.29$ ), but they would prefer to see them in reality ( ${\rm M} = 2.07$ ).

Examples of eLab Practical Courses

In Bordeaux 1 University, in the curricula of Bachelor of Electrical Engineering or Master of Microelectronics, students have practical teaching modules that follow the dual-approach circuit simulation/circuit measurement, for each electronic function. The measurement session is usually performed on customized boards with discrete components, but this situation has many drawbacks, as detailed hereafter. The following examples are taken among typical building blocks in analog circuits design, and illustrate the most significant advantages of using a remote platform like eLab.

6.1 Differential Amplifier

This building block is found at the input stage of all operational or transconductance amplifiers; its investigation by the electrical engineer students is of the highest importance. Different topologies exist for this function, with different performances. When using discrete components on a test board, the main difficulty comes from instabilities due to the density of wire connections and the generally high voltage gain. Even with the simpler topology (differential amplifier with long-tail resistance and resistive load), the test configurations (specific to differential or common modes) introduce other external components making the overall circuit quite complex.

The solution is to use a standard integrated circuit (CA3046), instead of discrete components, and realize a specific PCB for each test configuration, which considerably minimizes the connections. It is finally possible to characterize the most complex version of the differential amplifier in differential mode, with current mirrors as active load and active biasing circuits, as it is shown in Fig. 3.

Graphic: Fig. 3. Differential amplifier frequency characterization: (a) test circuit and (b) 
eLab measurement results.

Figure    Fig. 3. Differential amplifier frequency characterization: (a) test circuit and (b) eLab measurement results.

6.2 MOS Wilson Current Mirror

The current mirror is another widely used function in analog IC. The theoretical development generally describes a perfectly balanced structure and its performance (ability to duplicate a current) depends crucially on the transistors matching. This matching property is once again not realizable with discrete components. The solution is to use a specific IC (part of the previously mentioned Cyberchips) which implements a set of current mirror topologies. Furthermore, by embedding this specific IC in eLab remote platform, we avoid the delicate problem of chip manipulation: the circuit under test remains at a permanent place, while the switching matrix permits to configure different test circuits. In eLab, four different types of current mirror are available and the result of MOS Wilson mirror static characterization is shown in Fig. 4.

Graphic: Fig. 4. MOS Wilson current mirror output characterization: (a) test circuit and (b) 
eLab measurement results.

Figure    Fig. 4. MOS Wilson current mirror output characterization: (a) test circuit and (b) eLab measurement results.

6.3 Transistor Gummel Characterization

As the last example, we consider the transistor, which is the fundamental device in microelectronics. Students in an EE curriculum have generally teaching modules on Physics of Semi-conductor Devices, which permit to understand the transistor electrical characteristics. eLab platform gives access to a Semiconductor Parameter Analyzer (HP4145), which is an accurate research lab instrument. Furthermore, alone transistors (MOS or Bipolar) are available on the Cyberchips. For example, Fig. 5 shows the typical Gummel plot for a PNP transistor that student can perform with eLab. It is obvious that such costly equipment couldn't be duplicated in several stations.

Graphic: Fig. 5. Gummel plot for a PNP transistor: (a) test circuit and (b) 
eLab measurement results.

Figure    Fig. 5. Gummel plot for a PNP transistor: (a) test circuit and (b) eLab measurement results.


Practical experiments have a great importance in electrical engineering, not only to compare theory and practice, but also to learn how to employ research and industrial instruments. This paper has presented the eLab remote platform, in terms of history, architecture, use, and pedagogical interest. eLab is an Internet-based platform which relates the user to a set of electrical circuits and instruments. A huge number of real experiments can be performed through the Web, with a wide range of typical circuits in electrical engineering. Examples have been presented to show that eLab can solve several obstacles that usually disturb students' practical measurements. The eLab architecture offers a rapid access to the instruments and devices, without any booking procedure, and does not require any commercial software. After identification, the user is given access to a personal desk gathering his textbooks, notebooks, and previous measurements. The instructor can easily edit a textbook, using the test units' database, to create a personalized eLab session. In conclusion, eLab fits the main requirements of remote labs: availability, security, flexibility, portability, and limitation of implementation cost.

Today, eLab-based practical modules are concretely integrated in the curriculum of Bachelor of Electrical Engineering or Master of Microelectronics at Bordeaux 1 University. A recent cooperation with Sfax Superior Institute of Electronics and Communications (ISECS) has been leading to introduce an eLab module in the program of the ISECS institute since 2007 [ 25]. It has provided a significant impact on users' learning motivation. Future plans address the integration of the eLab platform into complete learning units that are accredited by European Credits Transfer System (ECTS), within a Learning Management Systems.


This work was supported by funds from the European ERASMUS-ECDEM Program under Contract No. 133844-LLP-1-2007 and the French UNIT project.


About the Authors

Bio Graphic
Noëlle Lewis received the PhD degree in microelectronics from Bordeaux University, France, in 1997. The topic of her PhD thesis was behavioral modeling of analog circuits. Since 2000, she has been an associate professor in IXL Microelectronics Lab, in the Design and Test Group. Her research interests include behavioral modeling of analog and mixed circuits, System on-Chip design optimization, and IP blocks library for Analog and Mixed Systems. She has been a member of the Forum on Specification and Design Languages (FDLs) program committee since 2002. She joined the "Engineering of Neuromorphic Systems" research team in 2005 to contribute to solve some critical points related to complex-mixed signal system integration and develop IP reuse techniques. Her teaching activities are in the domain of analog integrated circuits and CAD tools.
Bio Graphic
Michel Billaud received the PhD degree in applied mathematics (computer science speciality) from the Université of Bordeaux 1, France, in 1985. He joined the Institut Universitaire de Technologie de l'Université Bordeaux 1, where he teaches mainly about operating systems, programming, and networks. His research interests include formal semantics, graph rewriting, and e-learning. He has been involved in various e-learning projects in Bordeaux since 2000.
Bio Graphic
Didier Geoffroy received the MSc degree in applied physics from the University of Orsay, Paris, in 1980. He is currently an associate professor in the Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering at the University of Bordeaux and is also the head of the Pedagogical Lab Center of this department. His special interests include multimedia, open and distance learning, and the implementation of information and communication technologies (ICT) in practical courses.
Bio Graphic
Philippe Cazenave received the engineering degree from the "Ecole Nationale Supérieure d'Electronique et de Radiocommunications de Bordeaux" (ENSERB) and the PhD degree in electronics engineering from the University of Bordeaux in 1969 and 1972, respectively. Since 1972, he has been an assistant professor of electronics engineering at the University of Bordeaux, where at the beginning, he joined the Laboratory of Electronics, which later became the "Laboratoire d'Integration du Composant au Système" (IMS). Throughout his career, his works have always been focused around three master points: 1) the semiconductor memories, 2) the failure analysis of ICs, and 3) the modeling of electron devices.
Bio Graphic
Thomas Zimmer received the MSc degree in physics from the University of Würzburg, Germany, and the PhD degree in electronics from the University Bordeaux 1, France, in 1989 and 1992, respectively. From 1989 to 1990, he was with the Fraunhofer Institute in Erlangen, Germany, working on MESFET and HEMT compact modeling. From 1992 to 1993, he was a member of the research staff at the IXL Laboratory, Talence, France, working on modeling of high-speed Si bipolar devices and technology. From 1993 to 2002, he was an associate professor at the University of Bordeaux 1. Since 2003, he has been a professor in the Department of Applied Physics and Measurement Engineering at the Institute of Technology within the University Bordeaux 1, France. His education interests concern multimedia, open and distance learning, and the implementation of information and communication technologies (ICTs) in lab courses. In particular, he was the coordinator of two European projects in the framework of the Socrates-Minerva program. His research focuses on the characterization and modeling of high-frequency devices, in particular Si/SiGe heterojunction bipolar transistors and future emerging technologies like Carbon nanotube field effect transistors. He has been involved in a couple of National and European research projects. In particular, he initiated the European FP7 IP project DOTFIVE, which focuses on the development of a 500-GHz Si/Ge HBT technology enabling the future design of communication, imaging, or radar IC working at frequencies up to 160 GHz. At the microelectronics Lab IMS, he is a group leader of the research group "nanoelectronics." He is a cofounder of the company XMOD Technologies (, and has published more than 100 technical papers related to his research and innovative engineering education initiatives. He served on the program committee of the International Conference on Interactive Mobile and Computer-Aided Learning (IMCL '07) and currently serves on the program committee of the IEEE Bipolar/BiCMOS Circuits and Technology Meeting (BCTM), where he holds the CAD/modeling subcommittee chair. He has served as a reviewer for many journals including IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, the IEEE Sensors Journal, and the IEEE Solid State Electronics. He is a senior member of the IEEE.
60 ms
(Ver 3.x)