, The University of Texas at Austin
, Princeton University
, IBM T.J. Watson Research
Pages: pp. 8-10
IEEE Micro focuses on contemporary design issues facing chip and hardware system designers. We publish in-depth descriptions of new or soon-to-be-announced designs from the industry to highlight both the design and the design issues addressed. As a result, IEEE Micro is a very important source of information on a wide range of processor techniques used in the industry today.
As many readers are certainly aware, there are several important computer architecture conferences each year where researchers from academia and industry present papers that describe emerging issues and propose new ideas for addressing them. We thought that it might be interesting to identify representative "Top Picks" from these conferences over the past year, based on their industry relevance and interest to the largest possible segment of IEEE Micro's readership. This would give more visibility to these ideas, facilitate potential industry adoption, and provide wider recognition to the authors.
We invited the selected papers' authors to submit essentially the same paper on the same ideas, allowing updates on only minor new work done since the conference publication, along with rewriting and editing to tailor it to IEEE Micro audiences. Because of the abundance of excellent submissions and shortage of space, we invited some as short articles, where the authors had to significantly condense their original work.
As you might expect, it is difficult, even risky, for us to try to identify which papers represent the "top" ones and which might have the biggest impact on future industrial designs. Essentially, every submission we received represented excellent ideas, since each submission had already been selected and carefully peer-reviewed for a highly selective architecture conference. Each submission also represented an immense amount of thought and effort by an author or team of authors.
Although quantitative approaches have been advocated and widely used in research as a means for identifying promising ideas, there is still an art to computer architecture that you simply cannot quantify. In recognition of this fact, we allowed our review process to include some amount of qualitative assessment. As a result, these selections reflect our impressions of the work, and are only a very small set of representative "top" ideas. There were many excellent submissions that we did not have the space to include. In addition, we only considered work that that authors had described in a submitted abstract in response to our call for submissions, so it is also highly likely that there are some great ideas out there that this issue does not cover at all.
The call invited submissions on work published at any IEEE or ACM architecture conference between October 2002 and December 2003. It required the submissions to be abstracts, a few pages in length, describing the technical contributions along with statements about the work's potential industry relevance and why IEEE Micro readers would be interested.
In response, we received 72 submissions from papers originally published in the following conferences:
A subset of the editorial board read and reviewed all submitted abstracts. Those that received high marks on the numerical assessment or at least one "top 10" vote went out to an extended review team that included other editorial board members and other experts in the field. These additional reviews were used to select the "Top Picks" published in this issue. Throughout the process, conflict-of-interest situations, including authors from the same institution, were handled according to IEEE conference review rules, where the other review committee members who did not have a conflict of interest made decisions about an affected paper. Also, the editor in chief and associate editor in chief stipulated a ruling in which papers coauthored by either of them would not be eligible for consideration in this special issue.
With much difficulty, we selected 15 papers that cover a wide range of topics. Some were invited as regular length articles, others as short articles. They all contain interesting and promising ideas.
We hope that they inspire you to read the original work, contact the authors, and perhaps even spark some connections with design issues that you are working on.
Here, we give a loosely categorized breakdown of Micro's Top Picks.
We hope that you enjoy this special issue of IEEE Micro. It turned out to be one of the most challenging issues to pull together. This is our first attempt at an issue selecting Top Picks from architectural conferences; we will hone the process for next year, and welcome any constructive suggestions or comments you might have.