The Community for Technology Leaders
RSS Icon
Subscribe
Issue No.03 - Third Quarter (2012 vol.5)
pp: 196-207
Guy Avraham , Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva
Ilana Nisky , Stanford University, Stanford
Hugo L. Fernandes , Northwestern University Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Chicago
Daniel E. Acuna , Northwestern University Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Chicago
Konrad P. Kording , Northwestern University Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Chicago
Gerald E. Loeb , University of Southern California, Los Angeles
Amir Karniel , Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva
ABSTRACT
In the Turing test a computer model is deemed to “think intelligently” if it can generate answers that are indistinguishable from those of a human. We developed an analogous Turing-like handshake test to determine if a machine can produce similarly indistinguishable movements. The test is administered through a telerobotic system in which an interrogator holds a robotic stylus and interacts with another party—artificial or human with varying levels of noise. The interrogator is asked which party seems to be more human. Here, we compare the human-likeness levels of three different models for handshake: 1) Tit-for-Tat model, 2) λ model, and 3) Machine Learning model. The Tit-for-Tat and the Machine Learning models generated handshakes that were perceived as the most human-like among the three models that were tested. Combining the best aspects of each of the three models into a single robotic handshake algorithm might allow us to advance our understanding of the way the nervous system controls sensorimotor interactions and further improve the human-likeness of robotic handshakes.
INDEX TERMS
Humans, Muscles, Force, Computational modeling, Haptic interfaces, Robot sensing systems, Noise, turing test., Handshake, sensorimotor control, psychophysics, teleoperation
CITATION
Guy Avraham, Ilana Nisky, Hugo L. Fernandes, Daniel E. Acuna, Konrad P. Kording, Gerald E. Loeb, Amir Karniel, "Toward Perceiving Robots as Humans: Three Handshake Models Face the Turing-Like Handshake Test", IEEE Transactions on Haptics, vol.5, no. 3, pp. 196-207, Third Quarter 2012, doi:10.1109/TOH.2012.16
REFERENCES
[1] W.F. Chaplin, J.B. Phillips, J.D. Brown, N.R. Clanton, and J.L. Stein, "Handshaking, Gender, Personality, and First Impressions," J. Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 79, no. 1, pp. 110-117, 2000.
[2] G.L. Stewart, S.L. Dustin, M.R. Barrick, and T.C. Darnold, "Exploring the Handshake in Employment Interviews," J. Applied Psychology, vol. 93, no. 5, pp. 1139-1146, 2008.
[3] A.M. Turing, "Computing Machinery and Intelligence," Mind, a Quarterly Rev. of Psychology and Philosophy, vol. LIX, no. 236, 1950.
[4] G. Avraham, S. Levy-Tzedek, and A. Karniel, "Exploring the Rhythmic Nature of Handshake Movement and a Turing-Like Test," Proc. Fifth Computational Motor Control Workshop, 2009.
[5] A. Karniel, G. Avraham, B.-C. Peles, S. Levy-Tzedek, and I. Nisky, "One Dimensional Turing-Like Handshake Test for Motor Intelligence," J. Visualized Experiments, vol. 46, p. e2492, 2010.
[6] G. Avraham, I. Nisky, and A. Karniel, "When Robots Become Humans: A Turing-Like Handshake Test," Proc. Seventh Computational Motor Control Wokshop, 2011.
[7] I. Nisky, G. Avraham, and A. Karniel, "Three Alternatives to Measure the Human Likeness of a Handshake Model in a Turing-like Test," Presence, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 156-182, 2012.
[8] A. Karniel, I. Nisky, G. Avraham, B.-C. Peles, and S. Levy-Tzedek, "A Turing-Like Handshake Test for Motor Intelligence," Proc. Int'l Conf. Haptics: Generating and Perceiving Tangible Sensations, pp. 197-204, 2010.
[9] J.N. Bailenson, N. Yee, S. Brave, D. Merget, and D. Koslow, "Virtual Interpersonal Touch: Expressing and Recognizing Emotions Through Haptic Devices," Human Computer Interaction, vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 325-353, 2007.
[10] J. Bailenson and N. Yee, "Virtual Interpersonal Touch: Haptic Interaction and Copresence in Collaborative Virtual Environments," Multimedia Tools and Applications, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 5-14, 2008.
[11] J. Kim, H. Kim, B.K. Tay, M. Muniyandi, M.A. Srinivasan, J. Jordan, J. Mortensen, M. Oliveira, and M. Slater, "Transatlantic Touch: A Study of Haptic Collaboration over Long Distance," Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 328-337, 2004.
[12] M. McLaughlin, G. Sukhatme, P. Wei, Z. Weirong, and J. Parks, "Performance and Co-Presence in Heterogeneous Haptic Collaboration," Proc. 11th Symp. Haptic Interfaces for Virtual Environment and Teleoperator Systems (HAPTIC '03), 2003.
[13] J.P. Hespanha, M. McLaughlin, G.S. Sukhatme, M. Akbarian, R. Garg, and W. Zhu, "Haptic Collaboration over the Internet," Proc. Fifth PHANTOM Users Group Workshop, 2000.
[14] S. Gentry, E. Feron, and R. Murray-Smith, "Human-Human Haptic Collaboration in Cyclical Fitts' Tasks," Proc. IEEE/RSJ Int'l Conf. Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS '05), 2005.
[15] R. Groten, D. Feth, H. Goshy, A. Peer, D.A. Kenny, and M. Buss, "Experimental Analysis of Dominance in Haptic Collaboration," Proc. IEEE 18th Int'l Symp. Robot and Human Interactive Comm. (RO-MAN '09), 2009.
[16] N. Durlach and M. Slater, "Presence in Shared Virtual Environments and Virtual Togetherness," Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 214-217, 2000.
[17] R. Ikeura, H. Inooka, and K. Mizutani, "Subjective Evaluation for Manoeuvrability of a Robot Cooperating with Human," Proc. IEEE Eighth Int'l Workshop Robot and Human Interaction, 1999.
[18] M.M. Rahman, R. Ikeura, and K. Mizutani, "Investigation of the Impedance Characteristic of Human Arm for Development of Robots to Cooperate with Humans," JSME Int'l J. Series C Mechanical Systems, Machine Elements, and Manufacturing, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 510-518, 2002.
[19] Z. Wang, J. Lu, A. Peer, and M. Buss, "Influence of Vision and Haptics on Plausibility of Social Interaction in Virtual Reality Scenarios," Haptics: Generating and Perceiving Tangible Sensations, pp. 172-177, Springer, 2010.
[20] D. Feth, R. Groten, A. Peer, and M. Buss, "Haptic Human-Robot Collaboration: Comparison of Robot Partner Implementations in Terms of Human-Likeness and Task Performance," Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 173-189, 2011.
[21] M. Jindai, T. Watanabe, S. Shibata, and T. Yamamoto, "Development of Handshake Robot System for Embodied Interaction with Humans," Proc. IEEE 15th Int'l Symp. Robot and Human Interactive Comm., 2006.
[22] T. Kasuga and M. Hashimoto, "Human-Robot Handshaking Using Neural Oscillators," Proc. Int'l Conf. Robotics and Automation, 2005.
[23] K. Ouchi and S. Hashimoto, "Handshake Telephone System to Communicate with Voice and Force," Proc. IEEE Int'l Workshop Robot and Human Comm., pp. 466-471, 1997.
[24] J.N. Bailenson and N. Yee, "Virtual Interpersonal Touch and Digital Chameleons," J. Nonverbal Behavior, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 225-242, 2007.
[25] T. Miyashita and H. Ishiguro, "Human-Like Natural Behavior Generation Based on Involuntary Motions for Humanoid Robots," Robotics and Autonomous Systems, vol. 48, no. 4, pp. 203-212, 2004.
[26] Y. Kunii and H. Hashimoto, "Tele-Handshake Using Handshake Device," Proc. IEEE 21st Ann. Conf. Industrial Electronics (IECON '95), 1995.
[27] T. Sato, M. Hashimoto, and M. Tsukahara, "Synchronization Based Control Using Online Design of Dynamics and Its Application to Human-Robot Interaction," Proc. IEEE Int'l Conf. Robotics and Biomimetics (ROBIO '07), 2007.
[28] Z. Wang, A. Peer, and M. Buss, "An HMM Approach to Realistic Haptic Human-Robot Interaction," Proc. Third Joint EuroHaptics Conf. 2009.
[29] G. Loeb, I. Brown, and E. Cheng, "A Hierarchical Foundation for Models of Sensorimotor Control," Experimental Brain Research, vol. 126, no. 1, pp. 1-18, 1999.
[30] K.P. Kording and D.M. Wolpert, "Bayesian Decision Theory in Sensorimotor Control," Trends in Cognitive Sciences, vol. 10, no. 7, pp. 319-326, 2006.
[31] A.G. Feldman and M.F. Levin, "The Equilibrium-Point Hypothesis-Past, Present, and Future," Progress in Motor Control, vol. 629, pp. 699-726, 2009.
[32] R. Shadmehr and S.P. Wise, The Computational Neurobiology of Reaching and Pointing: A Foundation for Motor Learning. MIT Press, 2005.
[33] T. Flash and I. Gurevich, "Models of Motor Adaptation and Impedance Control in Human arm Movements," Self-Organization, Comutational Maps, and Motor Control, pp. 423-481, Elsevier Science, 1997.
[34] R. Shadmehr and F.A. Mussa-Ivaldi, "Adaptive Representation of Dynamics during Learning of a Motor Task," J. Neuroscience, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 3208-3224, 1994.
[35] J.R. Flanagan and A.M. Wing, "The Role of Internal Models in Motion Planning and Control: Evidence from Grip Force Adjustments during Movements of Hand-Held Loads," J. Neuroscience, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 1519-1528, 1997.
[36] J.R. Lackner and P. DiZio, "Rapid Adaptation to Coriolis Force Perturbations of Arm Trajectories," J. Neurophysiology, vol. 72, pp. 299-313, 1994.
[37] D.M. Wolpert and Z. Ghahramani, "Computational Principles of Movement Neuroscience," Nature Neuroscience, vol. 3, pp. 1212-1217, 2000.
[38] K.A. Thoroughman and R. Shadmehr, "Learning of Action through Adaptive Combination of Motor Primitives," Nature, vol. 407, no. 6805, pp. 742-747, 2000.
[39] A. Karniel and F.A. Mussa-Ivaldi, "Sequence, Time, or State Representation: How Does the Motor Control System Adapt to Variable Environments?" Biological Cybernetics, vol. 89, no. 1, pp. 10-21, 2003.
[40] H. Gomi and M. Kawato, "Equilibrium-Point Control Hypothesis Examined by Measured arm Stiffness during Multijoint Movement," Science, vol. 272, no. 5258, pp. 117-120, 1996.
[41] T. Flash and N. Hogan, "The Coordination of Arm Movements: An Experimentally Confirmed Mathematical Model," J. Neuroscience, vol. 5, no. 7, pp. 1688-1703, 1985.
[42] P. Morasso, "Spatial Control of Arm Movements," Experimental Brain Research, vol. 42, no. 2, pp. 223-227, 1981.
[43] T.B. Sheridan, "Further Musings on the Psychophysics of Presence," Proc. IEEE Int'l Conf. Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, "Humans, Information and Technology," 1994.
[44] T.B. Sheridan, "Further Musings on the Psychophysics of Presence," Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 241-246, 1996.
[45] G. Avraham, S. Levy-Tzedek, B.-C. Peles, S. Bar-Haim, and A. Karniel, "Reduced Frequency Variability in Handshake Movements of Individuals with Cerebral Palsy," Proc. Sixth Computational Motor Control Workshop, 2010.
[46] J.-F. Pilon and A. Feldman, "Threshold Control of Motor Actions Prevents Destabilizing Effects of Proprioceptive Delays," Experimental Brain Research, vol. 174, no. 2, pp. 229-239, 2006.
[47] R. Axelrod and W.D. Hamilton, "The Evolution of Cooperation," Science, vol. 211, no. 4489, pp. 1390-1396, 1981.
[48] A. Feldman, "Functional Tuning of the Nervous System with Control of Movement or Maintenance of a Steady Posture-II. Controllable Parameters of the Muscle," Biophysics, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 565-578, 1966.
[49] J.F. Pilon and A.G. Feldman, "Threshold Control of Motor Actions Prevents Destabilizing Effects of Proprioceptive Delays," Experimental Brain Research, vol. 174, no. 2, pp. 229-239, 2006.
[50] A.G. Feldman and M.F. Levin, "The Origin and Use of Positional Frames of Reference in Motor Control," Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol. 18, no. 4, pp. 723-744, 1995.
[51] P.L. Gribble, D.J. Ostry, V. Sanguineti, and R. Laboissi re, "Are Complex Control Signals Required for Human arm Movement?" J. Neurophysiology, vol. 79, no. 3, pp. 1409-1424, 1998.
[52] A.V. Hill, "The Heat of Shortening and the Dynamic Constants of Muscle," Proc. Royal Soc. of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, vol. 126, no. 843, pp. 136-195, 1938.
[53] G.A. Dudley, R.T. Harris, M.R. Duvoisin, B.M. Hather, and P. Buchanan, "Effect of Voluntary versus Artificial Activation on the Relationship of Muscle Torque to Speed," J. Applied Physiology, vol. 69, no. 6, pp. 2215-2221, 1990.
[54] Y. Yamato, M. Jindai, and T. Watanabe, "Development of a Shake-Motion Leading Model for Human-Robot Handshaking," SICE Ann. Conf., 2008.
[55] C.M. Bishop, Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning. Springer, 2006.
[56] G.A. Gescheider, Method, Theory, and Application. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1985.
[57] F. Wichmann and N. Hill, "The Psychometric Function: I. Fitting, Sampling, and Goodness of Fit," Perception and Psychophysics, vol. 63, no. 8, pp. 1293-1313, 2001.
[58] R. Davoodi and G.E. Loeb, "Physics-Based Simulation for Restoration and Rehabilitation of Movement Disorders," IEEE Trans. Biomedical Eng., In press.
[59] K.J. Kuchenbecker, J.G. Park, and G. Niemeyer, "Characterizing the Human Wrist for Improved Haptic Interaction," Proc. Int'l Mechanical Eng. Congress and Exposition (IMECE '03), 2003.
[60] V.M. Zatsiorsky, Kinetics of Human Motion. Human Kinetics, 2002.
[61] C.L. Baker, R. Saxe, and J.B. Tenenbaum, "Action Understanding as Inverse Planning," Cognition, vol. 113, no. 3, pp. 329-349, 2009.
[62] F. Everett, N. Proctor, and B. Cartmell, "Providing Psychological Services to American Indian Children and Families," Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 588-603, 1983.
[63] H.S. Woo and C. Prud'homme, "Cultural Characteristics Prevalent in the Chinese Negotiation Process," European Business Rev., vol. 99, no. 5, pp. 313-322, 1999.
[64] C.M. Laine, K.M. Spitler, C.P. Mosher, and K.M. Gothard, "Behavioral Triggers of Skin Conductance Responses and Their Neural Correlates in the Primate Amygdala," J. Neurophysiology, vol. 101, no. 4, pp. 1749-1754, 2009.
[65] J. Anttonen and V. Surakka, "Emotions and Heart Rate While Sitting on a Chair," Proc. SIGCHI Conf. Human Factors in Computing Systems, pp. 491-499, 2005.
[66] J. Freeman, S.E. Avons, R. Meddis, D.E. Pearson, and W. IJsselsteijn, "Using Behavioral Realism to Estimate Presence: A Study of the Utility of Postural Responses to Motion Stimuli," Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 149-164, 2000.
[67] D.W. Schloerb, "A Quantitative Measure of Telepresence," Presence: Teleoperators and Virtual Environments, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 64-80, 1995.
[68] K.B. Reed and M.A. Peshkin, "Physical Collaboration of Human-Human and Human-Robot Teams," IEEE Trans. Haptics, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 108-120, July-Dec. 2008.
[69] T. Ganel and M.A. Goodale, "Visual Control of Action but Not Perception Requires Analytical Processing of Object Shape," Nature, vol. 426, no. 6967, pp. 664-667, 2003.
[70] M.A. Goodale and A.D. Milner, "Separate Visoual Pathways for Perception and Action," Trends in Neurosciences, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 20-25, 1992.
[71] S. Aglioti, J.F.X. DeSouza, and M.A. Goodale, "Size-Contrast Illusions Deceive the Eye but Not the Hand," Current Biology, vol. 5, no. 6, pp. 679-685, 1995.
[72] A. Pressman, I. Nisky, A. Karniel, and F.A. Mussa-Ivaldi, "Probing Virtual Boundaries and the Perception of Delayed Stiffness," Advanced Robotics, vol. 22, pp. 119-140, 2008.
[73] I. Nisky, A. Pressman, C.M. Pugh, F.A. Mussa-Ivaldi, and A. Karniel, "Perception and Action in Teleoperated Needle Insertion," IEEE Trans. Haptics, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 155-166, May-June 2011.
[74] P. Tuffield and H. Elias, "The Shadow Robot Mimics Human Actions," Industrial Robot: An Int'l J., vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 56-60, 2003.
[75] H. Liu, P. Meusel, N. Seitz, B. Willberg, G. Hirzinger, M. Jin, Y. Liu, R. Wei, and Z. Xie, "The Modular Multisensory DLR-HIT-Hand," Mechanism and Machine Theory, vol. 42, no. 5, pp. 612-625, 2007.
[76] N. Wettels, V.J. Santos, R.S. Johansson, and G.E. Loeb, "Biomimetic Tactile Sensor Array," Advanced Robotics, vol. 22, no. 8, pp. 829-849, 2008.
[77] J.C. van der Heide, J.M. Fock, B. Otten, E. Stremmelaar, and M. Hadders-Algra, "Kinematic Characteristics of Reaching Movements in Preterm Children with Cerebral Palsy," Pediatric Research, vol. 57, no. 6, p. 883, 2005.
[78] L. Roennqvist and B. Roesblad, "Kinematic Analysis of Unimanual Reaching and Grasping Movements in Children with Hemiplegic Cerebral Palsy," Clinical Biomechanics, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 165-175, 2007.
[79] B. van Den, "Coordination Disorders in Patients With Parkinson's Disease: A Study of Paced Rhythmic Forearm Movements," Experimental Brain Research, vol. 134, no. 2, pp. 174-186, 2000.
12 ms
(Ver 2.0)

Marketing Automation Platform Marketing Automation Tool