This Article 
 Bibliographic References 
 Add to: 
About the Influence of Illumination Models on Image Comprehension in Direct Volume Rendering
Dec. 2011 (vol. 17 no. 12)
pp. 1922-1931
Florian Lindemann, University of Münster
Timo Ropinski, University of Münster
In this paper, we present a user study in which we have investigated the influence of seven state-of-the-art volumetric illumination models on the spatial perception of volume rendered images. Within the study, we have compared gradient-based shading with half angle slicing, directional occlusion shading, multidirectional occlusion shading, shadow volume propagation, spherical harmonic lighting as well as dynamic ambient occlusion. To evaluate these models, users had to solve three tasks relying on correct depth as well as size perception. Our motivation for these three tasks was to find relations between the used illumination model, user accuracy and the elapsed time. In an additional task, users had to subjectively judge the output of the tested models. After first reviewing the models and their features, we will introduce the individual tasks and discuss their results. We discovered statistically significant differences in the testing performance of the techniques. Based on these findings, we have analyzed the models and extracted those features which are possibly relevant for the improved spatial comprehension in a relational task. We believe that a combination of these distinctive features could pave the way for a novel illumination model, which would be optimized based on our findings.

[1] K. M. Beason, J. Grant, D. C. Banks, B. Futch, and M. Y. Hussaini, Pre-computed illumination for isosurfaces. In Conference on Visualization and Data Analysis, pages 1–11, 2006.
[2] C. Boucheny, G.-P. Bonneau, J. Droulez, G. Thibault, and S. Ploix, A perceptive evaluation of volume rendering techniques. In 4th Symp. on Applied perception in graphics and visualization, pages 83–90, 2007.
[3] B. Cabral, N. Cam, and J. Foran, Accelerated volume rendering and tomographic reconstruction using texture mapping hardware. In Symp. on Volume visualization, pages 91–98, 1994.
[4] M.-Y. Chan, Y. Wu, W.-H. Mak, W. Chen, and H. Qu, Perception-based transparency optimization for direct volume rendering. IEEE Trans. on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 15 (6): 1283–1290, 2009.
[5] E. Goldstein, Sensation and Perception, pages 179–184. Wadsworth, 2007.
[6] C. P. Gribble and S. G. Parker, An experimental design for determining the effects of illumination models in particle visualization. In APGV, page 175, 2005.
[7] M. Hadwiger, A. Kratz, C. Sigg, and K. Bühler, GPU-accelerated deep shadow maps for direct volume rendering. In ACM SIGGRAPH/EG Conference on Graphics Hardware, pages 27–28, 2006.
[8] F. Hernell, P. Ljung, and A. Ynnerman, Efficient ambient and emissive tissue illumination using local occlusion in multiresolution volume rendering. In IEEE/EG Int. Symp. on Volume Graphics, pages 1–8, 2007.
[9] F. Hernell, P. Ljung, and A. Ynnerman, Interactive global light propagation in direct volume rendering using local piecewise integration. In IEEE/EG Int. Symp. on Volume and Point-Based Graphics, pages 105– 112, 2008.
[10] H. H. Hu, A. A. Gooch, S. H. Creem-Regehr, and W. B. Thompson, Visual cues for perceiving distances from objects to surfaces. Presence: Teleoper. Virtual Environ., 11 (6): 652–664, 2002.
[11] G. S. Hubona, P. N. Wheeler, G. W. Shirah, and M. Brandt, The relative contributions of stereo, lighting, and background scenes in promoting 3D depth visualization. ACM Trans. Comput.-Hum. Interact., 6 (3): 214–242, 1999.
[12] D. Kersten, P. Mamassian, and D. Knill, Moving cast shadows and the perception of relative depth. Max-Planck-Institute for Biological Cybernetics Technical Report, 1994.
[13] R. Kittler, Standardisation of the outdoor conditions for the calculation of the daylight factor with clear skies. In Conf. Sunlight in Buildings, 1967.
[14] J. Kniss, S. Premoze, C. Hansen, and D. Ebert, Interactive translucent volume rendering and procedural modeling. In IEEE Visualization, pages 109–116, 2002.
[15] J. Kronander, D. Jonsson, J. Low, P. Ljung, A. Ynnerman, and J. Unger, Efficient visibility encoding for dynamic illumination in direct volume rendering. IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 2011.
[16] M. S. Langer and H. H. Bülthoff, Depth discrimination from shading under diffuse lighting. Perception, 29 (6): 649–660, 2000.
[17] M. Levoy, Display of surfaces from volume data. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 8 (3): 29–37, 1988.
[18] P. Ljung, F. Hernell, and A. Ynnerman, Local ambient occlusion in direct volume rendering. IEEE Trans. on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 15 (2), 2009.
[19] T. Luft, C. Colditz, and O. Deussen, Image enhancement by unsharp masking the depth buffer. ACM Trans. Graph., 25: 1206–1213, July 2006.
[20] K. Nicolaides, The Natural Way to Draw. Houghton Mifflin, 1941.
[21] M. Nulkar and K. Mueller, Splatting with shadows. In Volume Graphics, pages 35–50. Springer-Verlag, 2001.
[22] E. Penner and R. Mitchell, Isosurface ambient occlusion and soft shadows with filterable occlusion maps. In IEEE/EG Int. Symp. on Volume and Point-Based Graphics, pages 57–64, 2008.
[23] B. T. Phong, Illumination for computer generated pictures. Commun. ACM, 18 (6): 311–317, 1975.
[24] C. Rezk-Salama, M. Hadwiger, T. Ropinski, and P. Ljung, Advanced illumination techniques for GPU volume raycasting. In ACM SIGGRAPH Courses Program, 2009.
[25] T. Ritschel, Fast GPU-based Visibility Computation for Natural Illumination of Volume Data Sets. In Short Paper Eurographics 2007, pages 17–20, 2007.
[26] T. Ropinski, C. Döring, and C. Rezk-Salama, Interactive volumetric lighting simulating scattering and shadowing. In PacificVis 2010, pages 169– 176, 2010.
[27] T. Ropinski, J. Meyer-Spradow, S. Diepenbrock, J. Mensmann, and K. H. Hinrichs, Interactive volume rendering with dynamic ambient occlusion and color bleeding. Computer Graphics Forum (Eurographics), 27 (2): 567–576, 2008.
[28] M. Ruiz, I. Boada, I. Viola, S. Bruckner, M. Feixas, and M. Sbert, Obscurance-based volume rendering framework. In IEEE/EG Int. Symp. on Volume and Point-Based Graphics, pages 113–120, 2008.
[29] C. R. Salama, GPU-based monte-carlo volume raycasting. In Pacific Graphics, 2007.
[30] M. Schott, V. Pegoraro, C. Hansen, K. Boulanger, and K. Bouatouch, A directional occlusion shading model for interactive direct volume rendering. In Computer Graphics Forum (Eurographics/IEEE VGTC Symp. on Visualization), pages 855–862, 2009.
[31] A. J. Stewart, Vicinity shading for enhanced perception of volumetric data. In IEEE Visualization, page 47, 2003.
[32] E. Sundén, A. Ynnerman, and T. Ropinski, Image plane sweep volume illumination. IEEE TVCG (Vis Proceedings), 2011. Accepted.
[33] Y. Tao, H. Lin, H. Bao, F. Dong, and G. Clapworthy, Feature enhancement by volumetric unsharp masking. Vis. Comput., 25: 581–588, April 2009.
[34] V. Šoltészová, D. Patel, S. Bruckner, and I. Viola, A multidirectional occlusion shading model for direct volume rendering. Computer Graphics Forum, 29 (3): 883–891, 2010.
[35] V. Šoltészová, D. Patel, and I. Viola, Chromatic shadows for improved perception. In NPAR, 2011. Accepted.
[36] L. C. Wanger, The effect of shadow quality on the perception of spatial relationships in computer generated imagery. In Symp. on Interactive 3D graphics, pages 39–42, 1992.
[37] L. C. Wanger, J. A. Ferwerda, and D. P. Greenberg, Perceiving spatial relationships in computer-generated images. IEEE Comput. Graph. Appl., 12 (3): 44–51, 54–58, 1992.
[38] C. Weigle and D. Banks, A comparison of the perceptual benefits of linear perspective and physically-based illumination for display of dense 3d streamtubes. IEEE Trans. on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 14: 1723–1730, 2008.
[39] Y. Wu, H. Qu, K.-K. Chung, M.-Y. Chan, and H. Zhou, Quantitative effectiveness measures for direct volume rendered images. In PacificVis, pages 1–8, 2010.
[40] C. Wyman, S. Parker, P. Shirley, and C. Hansen, Interactive display of isosurfaces with global illumination. IEEE Trans. on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 12: 186–196, 2006.
[41] A. Yonas, Attached and Cast Shadows, pages 100–109. Praeger Publishers, 1979.
[42] C. Zhang and R. Crawfis, Volumetric shadows using splatting. In IEEE Visualization, pages 85–92, 2002.

Index Terms:
Volumetric illumination, volume rendering, spatial comprehension.
Florian Lindemann, Timo Ropinski, "About the Influence of Illumination Models on Image Comprehension in Direct Volume Rendering," IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, vol. 17, no. 12, pp. 1922-1931, Dec. 2011, doi:10.1109/TVCG.2011.161
Usage of this product signifies your acceptance of the Terms of Use.