Issue No.01 - January-March (2010 vol.9)
Published by the IEEE Computer Society
Maria R. Ebling , IBM T.J. Watson Research Center
Ramón Cáceres , AT&T Labs
DOI Bookmark: http://doi.ieeecomputersociety.org/10.1109/MPRV.2010.5
Recently released mobile phone services include Foursquare and Gowalla, location-based social networking services with a gaming element, and Metro Paris Subway, Yelp, and Urbanspoon, which add augmented-reality features to local-search applications.
Life as a Game
Foursquare ( www.foursquare.com) adds gaming aspects to location-based social networking applications for mobile phones. The more familiar features let users check in to the service with a status message and a location, such as a restaurant or a bar, and establish friend relationships to view each other's updates (see Figure 1a). The service's possible uses include finding out when friends are nearby and deciding where to go on a night out.
Other services such as Brightkite and Loopt offer similar functionality, but Foursquare's novel gaming element lets users compete for standing in the service by earning points, mayorships, and badges. Users obtain points when they check in on weeknights or weekends. The user who checks in to an establishment the most becomes that establishment's mayor—but only until someone else ousts him or her by topping the record. Users collect badges when they achieve milestones such as checking in to 25 unique venues or checking in after 3 a.m. on a weeknight (see Figure 1b). To encourage competition, the service maintains a leaderboard that ranks users by the number of points they obtained in the current week (see Figure 1c).
Gowalla ( www.gowalla.com) is similar to Foursquare—users check in at locations and compete for standing—but it has several notable differences. For instance, instead of points and badges, users obtain a passport stamp for each spot they visit (see Figure 2). Gowalla also has aspects of a scavenger hunt, wherein users collect virtual objects left in the places they visit. Finally, whereas Foursquare lets users manually specify a check-in location, Gowalla restricts check-ins to named spots determined by the mobile device's automatic-localization functions, such as GPS. Gowalla is thus less prone to users lying about their locations to gain an advantage, but it depends more on the automatic-localization function's availability and accuracy. We're interested in seeing how the trade-offs between automatic and manual localization play out in these and other location-based services.
Through their gaming components, Foursquare and Gowalla aim to not only increase use of their services but also encourage people to explore the cities they live in. In addition, both services let users publish their gaming achievements on other social services such as Facebook and Twitter.
Augmented Reality is Here
Advances in mobile hardware are quickly enabling commercial mobile application functionality that was, until recently, available only in research prototypes. For instance, mobile applications with augmented-reality functionality can superimpose computer-generated imagery on a live view of the physical world. These applications work with mobile devices that include a GPS receiver, a compass, and a camera, such as the HTC Android G1 and the Apple iPhone 3GS. The applications use the GPS receiver and compass to determine the phone's position and orientation. Using this information, they query a geographic database for relevant results, then superimpose a visualization of these results on a live camera feed.
Three local-search applications with augmented-reality features are Metro Paris Subway ( www.metroparisiphone.com/index_en.html), Yelp ( www.yelp.com), and Urbanspoon ( www.urbanspoon.com). Metro Paris Subway provides information about public transportation options and points of interest. Yelp and Urbanspoon allow browsing and searching for information about restaurants and similar businesses, including maps, directions, and reviews. Their augmented-reality features overlay information on a live camera view about points of interest lying in the direction the camera is pointing. Figure 3 shows examples of these overlays.
All three applications both exploit and depend on mobile phones' automatic-localization functions and, similar to Foursquare and Gowalla, exhibit trade-offs relative to manual localization. Urbanspoon makes explicit allowances for automatic-localization inaccuracies, letting users manually correct location errors by using the phone's touchscreen to move a location pointer on a map. Augmented-reality features still need work to function seamlessly on mobile devices, but they already show the exciting promise of things to come.